
After a week of living with the iPad I thought I’d share my early impressions.
Just to preface, I’m a heavy duty Mac user and currently have and use an iPhone 3GS, Apple TV, iMac and 17″ MacBook Pro.
I was very exited to get my hands on the new iPad and my very first impression exceeded expectations. The screen, the speed and the build quality were all excellent. My second impression was that it felt a little awkward to hold and use.
The apps, the specs and the quality are all great. My question going in was “is this the future format of mobile computing? Will this form factor replace laptops?” Before I even used the iPad I thought “yes” to both of these questions but now, I’m not so sure.
A few days in, I was at home browsing the web and doing some online shopping with the iPad. Just hanging out on the couch with the cat and TV in the background. After about 30 minutes I gave up and switched back to my laptop.
I’m just much faster and more productive with a keyboard and mouse than touch alone. When using the iPad for active browsing, your hands are usually supporting the device whereas a laptop is easier to position the screen and go hands free when reading or multi tasking (i.e. eating cereal.)
Touch screens are awesome and the iPad’s rocks. I just believe that a mouse is faster, more accurate and requires less physical movement to navigate the screen. I can forgive the iPhone’s touch keyboard because it’s on a device that fits in my pocket, but for typing up word docs or other productivity apps I want a real keyboard (yes you can get an external keyboard for the iPad but then why not just use a MacBook.)
The OS of the iPad is a great first start and feels very polished but I really missed having multiple windows open and apps running. I felt like I was using one of those school computers whose permissions keep you from doing anything other than open a couple of pre selected programs.
The iPad is an addition to your Mac arsenal, not a replacement for any one device. On planes or for specific app purposes (i.e. music sheet apps) where the form factor really works, the iPad is great. For using around the home, I’ll stick with my laptop.
With time can I grow to be more productive on an iPad? Absolutely, but with the iPhone it just felt right form the start. If I’m reaching for the laptop over the iPad, that’s not a great start.